Seth Beer 3.5/5 Stars

Updated: Dec 21, 2020
MLB Scouting Report - Robert Stangler
3 Stars= Average Player
4 Stars= Future All Star Player
5 Stars= Elite Player
Seth Beer 1B/OF (Diamondbacks) #14
The Report:
One of the main pieces in the 2019 Zack Greinke trade with the Houston Astros, Seth Beer shows signs of strong, flashy power from the left side and has great patience at the plate. In A+ and AA last year, he put up a .388 OBP with 26 home runs. Beer's swing can get long at times due to his stronger build, but he shows an athletic approach that can maintain some consistency at the big-league level. His foot work on defense needs improvement at first base and outfield. His defensive game is below average, even though in college he was adept at running outfield routes. He profiles more at first base or even at designated hitter.
His problems defensively and with strikeouts will likely keep him out of stardom, but Beer is a solid player with solid power. He can easily make up the strikeouts if he can walk like he did in the minors last year. He also isn’t your typical power hitter because he can go the other way with long balls.
Comps:
Right away the comps that jump out to me are Chris Davis, Joey Votto and Austin Meadows. By no means will Beer be either of them, but the swing is similar. Beer’s cut is free and easy, like Davis. They both supply solid pull power and seem effortless. The comp to Votto also makes sense because of the eye. Also, when Beer keeps the swing short, it has a Votto appearance. Beer’s body type is like Meadows, and they can both smash fastballs low or away in the zone.
Prediction:
Beer has power like Davis and a potential approach like Votto with a body style like Austin Meadows at a lower scale. This leads me to believe that 25-30 home runs is not out of the question. As far as the on base percentage, expect .360-.365. Beer also has such a solid approach. Pitchers can’t just throw away, like they can with other pull-happy hitters. He will attack the other way with authority at times and has shown gap-to-gap doubles power. His eye and power together will give him the upside of being a cleanup hitter, but if his swing stays long for too many years, he could be a No. 5 or 6 hitter.
Graded Tools:
Hit: 55/60
Run: 35/35
Field: 40/40
Power: 55/60
Arm: 45/45
Overall: 50/55
Comments